Riding herd on photons
A new ‘metamaterial’ prevents electromagnetic waves from reflecting backward,
pointing the way toward computer chips that move data with light.
To prevent microwaves passing through it from reflecting backward, a new 'metamaterial' uses antennas of alternating
orientations (top) that are connected by amplifier circuits (bottom).
Photo: Zheng Wang
August 3, 2012
Larry Hardesty, MIT News Office
Computer chips that use light to move data would be much more energy efficient and possibly even faster than today’s chips,
which use electricity. One of the difficulties in realizing them, however, is that light moving through a “waveguide” — unlike
electrons moving through a wire — can reflect backward, interfering with subsequent transmissions and even disrupting the
operation of the laser that emitted it.
Today’s optical networks keep light from reflecting backward with devices called isolators,
which are made from exotic materials like yttrium indium garnet and work only when a magnetic field is applied to them,
which makes them bulky. But since isolators absorb light particles — photons — to prevent them from scattering backward,
they also diminish the strength of forward-moving optical signals.
In this week’s Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, researchers at MIT, Zhejiang University in China,
and the University of Texas at Austin
describe a new “metamaterial”
that keeps photons moving in only one direction,
rechanneling the stragglers rather than simply absorbing them. Although the prototype is large, it doesn’t require the
application of a magnetic field, so it could, in principle, yield optical components much smaller than today’s isolators.
Moreover, building a chip-scale version of the metamaterial would require no materials more exotic than the metals already
used in microprocessors, reducing manufacturing costs.
With isolators, “you may not have reflection, but you lose light as light propagates in your structure,” says Zheng Wang,
who led the research as a postdoc and research scientist at MIT and is now an assistant professor of computer and electrical
engineering at the University of Texas. “Which is a big deal, because one of the reasons we don’t have large-scale integrated
optical devices is that loss limits how many devices we can integrate in the system.”
Wang’s co-authors on the paper are MIT physics professors Marin Soljacic and John Joannopoulos; Lixin Ran and Zhiyu Wang of
Zhejiang University; and MIT graduate students Jingyu Wang, Bin Zhang and Jiangtao Huangfu.
What gives the researchers’ new material its light-herding properties are rows of embedded metal antennas that look rather
like small, twin-blade propellers of alternating orientations, vertical and horizontal. Each antenna is connected by an electrical
circuit to an antenna of the opposite orientation on the bottom surface of the material; the direction of current flow through the
electrical circuits determines the direction in which electromagnetic waves will propagate.
In the prototype, the antennas are embedded in a pair of circuit boards about an inch apart, but in a chip, they could just as
easily be embedded in silicon. Indeed, miniaturizing the antennas is not the chief obstacle to getting the metamaterial to work
at visible-light or even near-infrared frequencies. The operating frequency is also limited by the switching speed of a transistor
in the electrical circuit, and no known transistor design yields a switching speed high enough for visible light.
“We probably need to use some nonlinear optics,” Wang says. “That’s something we’re still working on.”
“It’s pretty exciting work,” says Shanhui Fan, an associate professor of electrical engineering at Stanford University.
“It’s addressing an important problem.” While researchers are investigating a number of different approaches to chip-scale
waveguides, an optical version of the new metamaterial could be particularly useful in the manufacture of the on-chip devices
that control optical signals. Though the back-reflection in such devices can be mild, it compounds when a number of them are
used in sequence. “That turned out to be quite an issue if you need to cascade many of these devices together,” Fan says.
Fan’s own group is working on an approach to preventing back-scattering that works at optical frequencies.
“Scaling their approach up to a higher frequency would be a very exciting direction,” Fan says, but he adds,
“I imagine that there will be important applications in every frequency range.”